The Wildlife Trusts explore legal challenge to Government’s neonic decision

Charlotte Owen
, 27 January 2021
The Wildlife Trusts explore legal challenge to Government’s neonic decision
Red-tailed bumblebee ©Jon Hawkins - Surrey Hills Photography

The Wildlife Trusts’ lawyers have today contacted the Environment Secretary, George Eustice, to question his decision to allow the emergency use of the banned neonicotinoid Thiamethoxam for sugar beet. The Wildlife Trusts believe the action may have been unlawful and are planning a legal challenge to the decision unless Government can prove otherwise.

In 2018, the UK Expert Committee on Pesticides refused a similar application because of unacceptable environmental risks.1 The Wildlife Trusts contend that no new evidence has been provided since then to support the Government’s latest decision, and therefore the ban should remain in force.

The Wildlife Trusts argue that the Environment Secretary has not proved that there is no alternative to using neonicotinoids; nor has he explained what action he is taking to ensure the emergency authorisation is not repeated indefinitely. We are deeply concerned that the current derogation applies for three years, and that further derogations could be allowed for a further block of three years.

Craig Bennett, chief executive of The Wildlife Trusts, says:

“We are preparing to take legal action unless the Government can prove it acted lawfully. The Government refused a request for emergency authorisation in 2018 and we want to know what’s changed. Where’s the new evidence that it’s ok to use this extremely harmful pesticide?

“Only 5% of this toxic neonicotinoid goes where it is wanted in the crop; most ends up in the soil, where it can be absorbed by the roots of wildflowers, and also ends up in our rivers, potentially affecting other insects and wildlife.2

“This comes at a time when the Government has yet again delayed the vitally important Environment Bill, and which once more highlights the gap between the rhetoric and reality of the Government’s commitment to restoring nature and tackling the twin nature and climate crises.

“Over 56,000 people have signed The Wildlife Trusts’ petition in the last few days to ask the Prime Minister to overturn the neonics decision, and 40,000 people have emailed their MP. Every single MP has been emailed by a constituent on this matter.”

Sugar beet farmers who will potentially be using seeds dressed with Thiamethoxam will be preparing for this year’s crop shortly, so The Wildlife Trusts are seeking a response from George Eustice as a matter of urgency.

  

1 In 2018, the UK sugar beet industry submitted an application for an emergency authorisation for the use of “Poncho Beta” and “Cruiser SB” as neonicotinoid seed treatments on sugar beet. The UK Expert Committee on Pesticides refused the application on the grounds that there were a number of unacceptable environmental risks associated with the use of these products (specifically unacceptable effects to bees in following crops and flowering plants in field margins, birds and mammals eating seedlings from treated seed and birds consuming pelleted seed, and the impact of concentrations of Thiamethoxam in surface waters on populations of aquatic insects), and these would be concentrated in areas planted to sugar beet. More here

2 Analysis of official data by Buglife showed that 74% of freshwater sites monitored were contaminated with neonicotinoids. Chronic neonicotinoid pollution levels were exceeded in East Anglian and Lincolnshire rivers.  Analysis of official data by Buglife in 2017 found that 88% of river water samples in Britain were contaminated with neonicotinoids. 

Leave a comment

Comments

  • Nick Phillips:

    Well done The Wildlife Trusts for standing up to the Government on this. If our Parliament is too ineffective to prevent the Government from taking this action then the Courts it has to be.

    29 Jan 2021 13:15:00

Time Δ Debug Message - Perch Runway 3.2
1788110077.94150 [907] SELECT p.pagePath, pr.routePattern, pr.routeRegExp, p.pageTemplate, pr.routeOrder, s.settingValue AS siteOffline FROM swt_pages_staging p LEFT JOIN swt_page_routes pr ON p.pageID=pr.pageID LEFT JOIN swt_settings s ON s.settingID='siteOffline' UNION SELECT NULL AS pagePath, pr2.routePattern, pr2.routeRegExp, pr2.templatePath AS pageTemplate, pr2.routeOrder, NULL AS siteOffline FROM swt_page_routes pr2 WHERE templateID!=0 ORDER BY routeOrder ASC, pagePath ASC
1788110077.9720.0305Matched route: news/[slug:s]
1788110077.97210.0001Server address: 216.73.217.60
1788110077.97220Using master page: /templates/pages/blog/post.php
1788110077.97220Page arguments: 
Array
(
    [0] => /news/the-wildlife-trusts-explore-legal-challenge-to-governments-neonic-decision
    [s] => the-wildlife-trusts-explore-legal-challenge-to-governments-neonic-decision
    [1] => the-wildlife-trusts-explore-legal-challenge-to-governments-neonic-decision
)
1788110077.97250.0003 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/news/post' LIMIT 1
1788110077.97350.0011 [86] SELECT DISTINCT settingID, settingValue FROM swt_settings WHERE userID=0
1788110077.97560.0021 [1] SELECT locationID FROM swt_shop_tax_locations WHERE locationIsHome=1 LIMIT 1
1788110077.97650.0009INSERT INTO swt_shop_cart(memberID,locationID,currencyID,cartPricing,cartProperties) VALUES(NULL,'1',47,'standard','[]')
1788110077.98020.0037 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_shop_cart WHERE cartID=24622510
1788110077.9810.0009 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_shop_cart WHERE cartID=24622510
1788110077.98190.0009 [nil] SELECT * FROM swt_shop_sales WHERE saleFrom<='2026-08-30 17:14:00' AND saleTo>'2026-08-30 17:14:00' AND saleActive=1 AND saleDeleted IS NULL ORDER BY saleOrder ASC
1788110077.98330.0014 [1] SELECT SQL_CALC_FOUND_ROWS DISTINCT tbl.* FROM ( SELECT idx.itemID, main.*, idx2.indexValue as sortval FROM swt_blog_index idx JOIN swt_blog_posts main ON idx.itemID=main.postID AND idx.itemKey='postID' JOIN swt_blog_index idx2 ON idx.itemID=idx2.itemID AND idx.itemKey='postID' AND idx2.indexKey='_id' WHERE 1=1 AND ((idx.indexKey='postSlug' AND idx.indexValue='the-wildlife-trusts-explore-legal-challenge-to-governments-neonic-decision')) AND idx.itemID=idx2.itemID AND idx.itemKey=idx2.itemKey GROUP BY idx.itemID, idx2.indexValue, postID ) as tbl WHERE (postStatus='Published' AND postDateTime<='2026-08-30 17:14:00' ) GROUP BY itemID, sortval ORDER BY sortval ASC LIMIT 0, 10
1788110077.9880.0047 [1] SELECT FOUND_ROWS() AS `count`
1788110077.98870.0007 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_blog_posts WHERE postID=2441 AND postStatus='Published' AND postDateTime<='2026-08-30 17:14:00'
1788110077.98980.0011 [13] SELECT * FROM swt_blog_sections ORDER BY sectionTitle ASC
1788110077.99060.0008 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_blogs ORDER BY blogTitle ASC
1788110077.99160.001 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_categories WHERE catID=40 LIMIT 1
1788110077.99260.001Using template: /templates/blog/post.html
1788110077.99290.0003 [162] SELECT catID, catPath FROM swt_categories
1788110077.9940.0012 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_blog_posts WHERE postStatus='Published' AND postDateTime<='2026-08-30 17:14:00' AND postSlug='the-wildlife-trusts-explore-legal-challenge-to-governments-neonic-decision'
1788110078.0240.0299Using template: /templates/blog/post.html
1788110078.02460.0006 [250] SELECT country, countryID FROM swt_shop_countries WHERE countryActive=1 ORDER BY country ASC
1788110078.02810.0035Using template: /templates/pages/attributes/seo.html
1788110078.02840.0003 [1] SELECT regionID, regionTemplate, regionPage, regionRev AS rev FROM swt_content_regions WHERE regionKey='Banner image' AND (regionPage='/news/post' OR regionPage='*')
1788110078.02950.0011 [nil] SELECT * FROM ( SELECT idx.itemID, c.regionID, idx.pageID, c.itemJSON, idx2.indexValue as sortval FROM swt_content_index idx JOIN swt_content_items c ON idx.itemID=c.itemID AND idx.itemRev=c.itemRev AND idx.regionID=c.regionID JOIN swt_content_index idx2 ON idx.itemID=idx2.itemID AND idx.itemRev=idx2.itemRev AND idx2.indexKey='_order' WHERE ((idx.regionID=104 AND idx.itemRev=0)) AND idx.itemID=idx2.itemID AND idx.itemRev=idx2.itemRev ) as tbl GROUP BY itemID, pageID, itemJSON, sortval, regionID ORDER BY sortval ASC
1788110078.03110.0015 [82] SELECT * FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageNew=0 AND pageHidden=0 AND pageDepth >=0 AND pageDepth<=2 ORDER BY pageTreePosition ASC
1788110078.03670.0056 [1] SELECT pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/news/post' LIMIT 1
1788110078.03780.0011 [2] SELECT pageID FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition IN ('000-006-001', '000-006', '000') ORDER BY pageTreePosition DESC
1788110078.04120.0034Using template: /templates/navigation/ps_nav_template.html
1788110078.04130.0001 [6] Using template: /templates/navigation/ps_nav_template_children.html
1788110078.04210.0008 [4] Using template: /templates/navigation/ps_nav_template_children.html
1788110078.04270.0006 [29] Using template: /templates/navigation/ps_nav_template_children.html
1788110078.04510.0024 [10] Using template: /templates/navigation/ps_nav_template_children.html
1788110078.04610.001 [7] Using template: /templates/navigation/ps_nav_template_children.html
1788110078.04680.0007 [9] Using template: /templates/navigation/ps_nav_template_children.html
1788110078.04930.0024 [1] SELECT pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/news/post' OR pageSortPath='/news/post' LIMIT 1
1788110078.05040.0011 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageHidden=0 AND pageNew=0 AND pageTreePosition IN ('000-006-001', '000-006', '000') ORDER BY pageTreePosition
1788110078.05350.0031 [1] Using template: /templates/navigation/breadcrumbs.html
1788110078.05410.0005Using template: /templates/blog/post.html
1788110078.05430.0003 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_blog_authors WHERE authorID='16' LIMIT 1
1788110078.05530.001Using template: /templates/blog/author.html
1788110078.05570.0004 [1] SELECT SQL_CALC_FOUND_ROWS DISTINCT tbl.* FROM ( SELECT idx.itemID, main.*, idx2.indexValue as sortval FROM swt_blog_index idx JOIN swt_blog_posts main ON idx.itemID=main.postID AND idx.itemKey='postID' JOIN swt_blog_index idx2 ON idx.itemID=idx2.itemID AND idx.itemKey='postID' AND idx2.indexKey='_id' WHERE 1=1 AND ((idx.indexKey='postSlug' AND idx.indexValue='the-wildlife-trusts-explore-legal-challenge-to-governments-neonic-decision')) AND idx.itemID=idx2.itemID AND idx.itemKey=idx2.itemKey GROUP BY idx.itemID, idx2.indexValue, postID ) as tbl WHERE (postStatus='Published' AND postDateTime<='2026-08-30 17:14:00' ) GROUP BY itemID, sortval ORDER BY sortval ASC LIMIT 0, 1
1788110078.05810.0024 [1] SELECT FOUND_ROWS() AS `count`
1788110078.05890.0007 [1] Using template: /templates/blog/post.html
1788110078.06070.0019Using template: /templates/blog/comment_form.html
1788110078.06170.001 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_blog_comments WHERE 1=1 AND postID=2441 AND commentStatus='LIVE' ORDER BY FIELD(webmentionType, 'like', 'repost', 'comment', NULL) ASC, commentDateTime ASC
1788110078.13920.0775 [1] Using template: /templates/blog/comment.html
1788110078.13990.0007Using template: /templates/blog/post.html
1788110078.14010.0002 [1] SELECT * FROM swt_blog_authors WHERE authorID='16' LIMIT 1
1788110078.1410.0009 [1] SELECT pageID, pageParentID, pageDepth, pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/what-we-do' OR pageSortPath='/what-we-do' LIMIT 1
1788110078.1420.001 [1] SELECT pageID, pageParentID, pageDepth, pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition='000-002' LIMIT 1
1788110078.14280.0008 [7] SELECT * FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageNew=0 AND pageHidden=0 AND pageTreePosition LIKE '000-002%' AND pageDepth >=1 AND pageDepth<=2 ORDER BY pageTreePosition ASC
1788110078.14610.0033 [1] SELECT pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/news/post' LIMIT 1
1788110078.14680.0007 [2] SELECT pageID FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition IN ('000-006-001', '000-006', '000') ORDER BY pageTreePosition DESC
1788110078.14970.0028 [6] Using template: /templates/navigation/footer-nav.html
1788110078.15050.0008 [1] SELECT pageID, pageParentID, pageDepth, pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/make-a-difference' OR pageSortPath='/make-a-difference' LIMIT 1
1788110078.15130.0008 [1] SELECT pageID, pageParentID, pageDepth, pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition='000-005' LIMIT 1
1788110078.15190.0006 [38] SELECT * FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageNew=0 AND pageHidden=0 AND pageTreePosition LIKE '000-005%' ORDER BY pageTreePosition ASC
1788110078.15530.0034 [1] SELECT pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/news/post' LIMIT 1
1788110078.15610.0007 [2] SELECT pageID FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition IN ('000-006-001', '000-006', '000') ORDER BY pageTreePosition DESC
1788110078.1590.003 [10] Using template: /templates/navigation/footer-nav.html
1788110078.16220.0031 [1] SELECT pageID, pageParentID, pageDepth, pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/visit' OR pageSortPath='/visit' LIMIT 1
1788110078.16310.001 [1] SELECT pageID, pageParentID, pageDepth, pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition='000-004' LIMIT 1
1788110078.16380.0007 [30] SELECT * FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageNew=0 AND pageHidden=0 AND pageTreePosition LIKE '000-004%' AND pageDepth >=1 AND pageDepth<=2 ORDER BY pageTreePosition ASC
1788110078.16730.0035 [1] SELECT pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/news/post' LIMIT 1
1788110078.1680.0007 [2] SELECT pageID FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition IN ('000-006-001', '000-006', '000') ORDER BY pageTreePosition DESC
1788110078.17090.0029 [29] Using template: /templates/navigation/footer-nav.html
1788110078.17320.0022 [1] SELECT pageID, pageParentID, pageDepth, pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/make-a-difference' OR pageSortPath='/make-a-difference' LIMIT 1
1788110078.1740.0009 [1] SELECT pageID, pageParentID, pageDepth, pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition='000-005' LIMIT 1
1788110078.17470.0006 [11] SELECT * FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageNew=0 AND pageHidden=0 AND pageTreePosition LIKE '000-005%' AND pageDepth >=1 AND pageDepth<=2 ORDER BY pageTreePosition ASC
1788110078.1780.0033 [1] SELECT pageTreePosition FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pagePath='/news/post' LIMIT 1
1788110078.17860.0006 [2] SELECT pageID FROM swt_pages_staging WHERE pageTreePosition IN ('000-006-001', '000-006', '000') ORDER BY pageTreePosition DESC
1788110078.18140.0028 [10] Using template: /templates/navigation/footer-nav.html
1788110078.18210.0008Request time: 0.243
1788110078.18210Process time: 0.2429
1788110078.18210Memory: 1.6278